Recent searches
Search options
Ok, now on to Reviewer 1's comments. This is the reviewer who, recall REDID MY STATS FOR ME. (It's not quite that simple, but it still embodies the contrast between a picky review that pretends to be helpful, and an actually helpful review.) Even the comments are just *nice*. Like, 'I think your decision to do [x] is not useful, but it's a matter of taste, so I won't make a fuss'
Or this one!
"Perhaps, if you find it interesting, this [reference] could be mentioned in your literature review in the introduction."
I emphasize, this isn't some passive-aggressively phrased requirement. In context, it's clear that this is just a NICE comment that highlights a thing I might find helpful, but doesn't insist that I add references that aren't relevant!