@tomstearns If you're looking for a serious answer, I'd also get some non-fizzy and/or nonalcoholic drinks (very likely someone will really appreciate apple juice), a fruit plate, and one of those two-pound bags of M&Ms. Also make sure you ask about and accommodate any allergies or other dietary restrictions (other including vegetarian/vegan/kosher/halal), or it's not much of a party for those who can't partake.
@DialMforMara OK they made me cry. Gave me a card and everything. And one of them sang songs. The rest played Cards Against Humanity.
Kids these days.
@tomstearns Sounds like a lovely evening!
@DialMforMara Those are great suggestions. Thanks! We have some vegetarians, a few who might want kosher, but I forgot about allergies until you mentioned it. Thanks!